Gay Marriage Approval Death Knell for Anglican Unity

Anglican Bishop Gene Robinson

Bishops in the US dealt a death blow to hopes for unity in the worldwide Anglican Church when they approved in principle services for same-sex partnerships. The decision will finally split the Communion between Bible-based conservative evangelicals and liberal modernisers.

The bishops at the Episcopal General Convention voted by 104 to 30 to “collect and develop theological resources and liturgies” for blessing same-sex relationships, to be considered at the next convention in 2012.

The resolution notes the growing number of states that allow gay marriage, civil unions and domestic partnerships, and gives bishops in those regions discretion to provide a “generous pastoral response” to couples in local parishes. It was passed on Wednesday [July 15, 2009] hours after the Episcopal Church voted on Tuesday [July 14, 2009] to allow the consecration of gay bishops. The motion passed by 99 to 45 among the bishops and by 72 per cent to 28 per cent among church deputies, made up of clergy and laity.

The decisions on gay consecrations and same-sex blessings end the uneasy truce agreed after the consecration of the openly gay Gene Robinson (pictured left) as Bishop of New Hampshire in 2003.

In a closed session at Anaheim, an ad hoc committee of bishops had been asked to study the resolution to find ways to keep the Episcopal Church within the bounds of the Anglican Communion while also allowing for same-sex blessings. However, Bishop Mark Lawrence, a conservative from South Carolina, said that an accommodation would not work. “I’m not interested in tweaking this,” he said. “It’s not the train that’s the problem — it’s the direction it’s going.”

At the start of the convention last week, Dr Williams said in a sermon to delegates: “I hope and pray that there won’t be decisions in the coming days that could push us farther apart.” At the General Synod in York at the weekend, he told friends he was confident that Episcopal Church leaders would take his concerns seriously.

Lambeth Palace declined to comment as the decisions taken by the Episcopal Church’s leaders showed that they saw no reason to place the concerns of the “mother Church” in England above the demands of their own worshippers.

Source: The Times (July 17, 2009)

You may also like: